I like to imagine that they kinda met Gold because he gives off pretty demon-ish vibes so they assumed that he’s a demon in disguise and bring up demon/angel/whatever stuff with him and Gold’s like “wait… I’m a human. you know that right?”

“seriously? I could have sworn you were a lust demon or something, I mean, you were trying to seduce two people at once.”

“um, ‘befriend’ two people at once. Seducing comes later,” *eyebrow wiggle* “and yeah, I’m not even that lustful of a guy, just lonely.”

(Silver refers to himself as a demon because “I’m a fallen angel, like Satan himself, king of the demons.” But Crystal and Gold are like “nooooooo!!!! It’s not your faultttt!!!!” and try to find a way for him to go back to heaven. Even though it would mean they’d be separated from him because Crystal’s a demon and Gold’s smooched her so he’s probably not going to heaven)